Voltaren gel is stronger and directly tackles pain because of its NSAID ingredient. Biofreeze, with menthol, offers quick relief but is safer for regular use. However, both only give short-term relief. For lasting benefits, there is a supplement version of Voltaren that contains ingredients that help with inflammation and joint health. Still, Voltaren joint supplement isn’t the most comprehensive formula we’ve seen. With some research, you can find joint supplements with an array of proven ingredients like glucosamine and turmeric that should give you concrete long-term benefits.
About the Products
Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel: Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel is a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory gel specifically designed to treat arthritis pain. Formerly available only through a prescription, it has now been made available over-the-counter and has been trusted by both patients and doctors in the U.S. for over a decade. The gel is formulated to be non-greasy and has a clean scent, making it user-friendly. It works by targeting pain directly at its source, delivering clinically-proven nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medicine for effective pain relief. Additionally, Voltaren has introduced a dietary supplement, Voltaren Joint Comfort & Movement, for those who prefer capsules with natural ingredients over gel.
Biofreeze: Biofreeze is a topically applied pain relief solution that is trusted by pharmacists, physical therapists, chiropractors, and even athletic trainers. It offers a “unique” (in their words) cooling menthol formula that is backed by scientific research, ensuring fast-acting, long-lasting, and deep-penetrating pain relief for a variety of ailments, including sore muscles, backaches, sore joints, and arthritis. Unlike many other pain relief solutions, Biofreeze is not tested on animals and is free from NSAIDs, parabens, and propylene glycol. It is available in various versions, including gel, spray, roll-on, and more, all of which are based on menthol, its only active ingredient.
Ingredients
Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel: The primary active ingredient in Voltaren Gel is Diclofenac sodium (NSAID†) 1% (equivalent to 0.93% diclofenac). This ingredient is responsible for its anti-inflammatory properties and its ability to provide pain relief.
The Voltaren Joint Comfort & Movement Dietary Supplement, on the other hand, contains Turmeric Extract (500mg) and Boswellia Serrata extract (100mg). Both of these ingredients are known for their anti-inflammatory properties and their ability to support joint health.
Biofreeze: The sole active ingredient in Biofreeze is Menthol, which is present at a concentration of 4%. Menthol is a natural cooling agent that provides a sensation counteracting the burning and pain in muscles and joints. However, it’s essential to note that while menthol provides a cooling sensation, it doesn’t treat the root cause of the pain but rather masks it.
Which Formula Looks Better?
Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel: Voltaren stands out due to its use of Diclofenac sodium, a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID). This ingredient directly targets and reduces inflammation, which is often the root cause of joint pain, especially in arthritis. The gel’s ability to block the production of pain-signaling chemicals called prostaglandins gives it an edge in providing relief at the source of pain. Additionally, the dietary supplement version offers the benefits of Turmeric and Boswellia Serrata extracts, both of which are renowned for their anti-inflammatory properties.
Biofreeze: Biofreeze’s formula is centered around the cooling effects of Menthol. While Menthol is effective in providing a temporary soothing sensation and masking pain, it doesn’t address the underlying cause of the pain. It’s a surface-level relief agent, which means that while it can offer immediate comfort, it might not be as effective for chronic or severe pain conditions. The absence of NSAIDs or other anti-inflammatory agents means that Biofreeze might not provide the same depth of relief as Voltaren. But, it is certainly healthier for daily use than Voltaren, which, due to its NSAID ingredient, can cause side effects.
People’s Experiences
Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel: Users have expressed trust in Voltaren, especially given its history as a prescription product. Many appreciate its non-greasy formulation and the absence of a strong medicinal odor. The gel’s ability to target pain directly at its source has been highlighted positively by users. However, some third-party reviews caution about the potential side effects of NSAIDs and suggest that it might not be an ideal long-term solution.
Biofreeze: Biofreeze enjoys a favorable rating on platforms like Amazon, with many users praising its cooling effect and the immediate relief it provides. Some users have mentioned its ease of application and the absence of a lingering medicinal smell. However, reviews are mixed when it comes to the duration of relief, with some users noting that the effect wears off relatively quickly. A few users also mentioned that the gel version might not be as effective as the spray variant.
Recommendation for Different Groups
For Occasional Pain Sufferers:
- Voltaren: Suitable for those experiencing occasional flare-ups of arthritis or joint pain. The gel provides targeted relief and can be applied directly to the affected area. However, it’s essential to be cautious about prolonged use due to the presence of NSAIDs.
- Biofreeze: An excellent choice for individuals with sporadic muscle or joint discomfort. The cooling sensation of menthol offers immediate relief, making it ideal for post-workout soreness or minor strains. But it’s not as strong as Voltaren.
For Chronic Pain Sufferers:
- Voltaren: Recommended for individuals with chronic arthritis pain. The anti-inflammatory properties of Diclofenac sodium can provide more sustained relief. Those interested in a more holistic approach might consider the Voltaren dietary supplement with Turmeric and Boswellia Serrata extracts.
- Biofreeze: While it offers immediate relief, Biofreeze might not be the best long-term solution for chronic pain sufferers due to its masking effect. However, it can be used in conjunction with other treatments for added comfort.
For Athletes:
- Voltaren: Athletes with joint pain or inflammation might benefit from the targeted relief offered by Voltaren gel. It can be applied post-training to alleviate discomfort.
- Biofreeze: Highly favored by athletes for its fast-acting relief. The various application methods, especially the spray, make it convenient for on-the-go use.
For Elderly Individuals:
- Voltaren: Given its history and trustworthiness, it’s a suitable option for the elderly, especially those with arthritis pain. However, it’s crucial to consult with a healthcare professional before use.
- Biofreeze: The menthol-based formula can provide immediate comfort for common aches and pains experienced by the elderly. The absence of NSAIDs makes it a safer option for daily use.
Pricing
Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel: A 3.53oz (100g) tube of Voltaren gel is priced at $21.99 on its official website. Additionally, the Voltaren Joint Comfort & Movement supplement is available for $18.48 for a 30-ct bottle on its site.
Biofreeze: Biofreeze gel is available at approximately $10 per tub, with the price varying based on size and the purchasing platform.
Both products offer competitive pricing, with Voltaren having a slightly higher price point due to its pharmaceutical-grade ingredients. Biofreeze, on the other hand, provides a more budget-friendly option for those seeking natural relief for minor pains and aches.
The Bottom Line
Voltaren Arthritis Pain Gel stands out as a clinically-proven nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory treatment, targeting pain directly at its source. With over a decade of trust in the U.S., it offers a more medical approach to pain relief, especially for those with chronic arthritis. The added option of a dietary supplement with natural ingredients like Turmeric and Boswellia Serrata extract provides an alternative for those seeking holistic solutions.
On the other hand, Biofreeze offers immediate, cooling relief through its menthol-based formula. As the #1 clinically recommended brand by healthcare professionals, it’s a trusted choice for quick and temporary relief from minor aches and pains. Its wide range of application methods, from gels to sprays, offers versatility to users.
However, it’s essential to note that while Biofreeze provides immediate relief, it primarily masks the pain rather than treating its root cause. Voltaren, with its NSAID component, offers a more targeted approach to pain relief but comes with its own considerations regarding prolonged use. Neither one is the best for long-term use. If you want to support all aspects of your joint health in the long run – including flexibility, connective tissue repair, and pain relief – you will want to look into the market leading joint supplements.
Further Reading: